Richard Golian

1995-born. Charles University alum. Head of Performance at Mixit. 10+ years in marketing and data.

Castellano Français Slovenčina

Manage subscription Choose a plan

RSS
Newsletter
New articles to your inbox

Article

Stock Market Optimism and Media Manipulation

How financial media misleads investors
Richard Golian
Richard Golian · 2 174 reads
Hi, I am Richard. On this blog I share my thoughts, not investment advice. This is not a recommendation to buy or sell securities.
Listen to this article
0:00 / 0:00

January 2025

Yesterday, I witnessed a glaring example of media misinformation while watching a Slovak TV channel. During the prime-time news, the report confidently claimed that the growth of the S&P 500 index was directly tied to the growth of corporate earnings. Accompanied by charts of recent stock price developments, this narrative was presented as fact, but it was nothing more than an overly optimistic distortion. It was yet another example of the excessive optimism I highlighted in December 2024.

The reality tells a very different story. Over the past two years, the earnings of American companies in the S&P 500 index have not kept pace with their share prices. Stock prices have risen dramatically faster, resulting in a historically high price-to-earnings (PE) ratio. This valuation metric, which is public and readily accessible, reflects heightened expectations for future earnings growth, expectations now at historically elevated levels.

The market is brimming with optimism, but is it truly justified?

Such a wide gap between share prices and underlying earnings often signals trouble ahead. Whether through price corrections or long-term stagnation, the current market dynamic suggests that this optimism may soon face a harsh reality.

As I wrote before, this is not a reason to panic, but it is a reason to pause, ask questions, and ensure decisions are based on facts rather than narratives.

Disclaimer

This article is intended for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute financial advice, a recommendation to buy or sell any securities, or a guarantee of future market performance. The views expressed are solely those of the author, who may also be an investor. Investing in financial markets involves risk, and each reader should make their own decisions independently and, if necessary, consult with a licensed professional.

Summary

In January 2025 I watched a Slovak prime-time news report claim the S&P 500 rises in step with corporate earnings. It does not. Prices have climbed far faster, pushing the P/E ratio to historic highs. Such gaps usually come before a correction. I check the claims against public data. So should you.

Common questions on this article's topic

Can financial media present misleading narratives about the stock market?
Yes. In the article, a specific example is described: a Slovak TV channel claimed during prime-time news that S&P 500 growth was directly tied to earnings growth. But the data showed the opposite. Stock prices had risen dramatically faster than earnings over the previous two years, creating historically elevated P/E ratios. Research confirms that financial media bias is documented, with coverage varying significantly by outlet and influencing trading behaviour.
What does a high price-to-earnings ratio actually tell us?
A high P/E ratio means investors are paying more for each unit of company earnings than they have historically. In the article, this is described as reflecting heightened expectations for future earnings growth, expectations that by early 2025 had reached historically elevated levels. The CAPE ratio stood at approximately 38, the forward P/E at roughly 22x against an 18x historical median. These metrics are publicly accessible but rarely discussed in mainstream financial news.
How do financial media amplify unjustified market optimism?
In the article, a specific mechanism is described: confident TV reports accompanied by charts present distortions as fact, and viewers who lack the tools to verify accept these narratives. Research shows that journalist connections to company management lead to more favourable coverage, media disproportionately highlights dramatic developments, and politically polarised outlets frame financial news differently. The result is a feedback loop where media optimism reinforces market optimism, even when the underlying data tells a different story.
How can investors protect themselves from media-driven narratives?
In the article, the recommendation is to base decisions on verifiable data rather than media stories. P/E ratios, CAPE ratios, and earnings growth figures are publicly accessible. Comparing what the media claims with what the numbers actually show is the simplest defence against misleading narratives. The core principle remains: ask what you are getting for the price you are paying, and verify the answer yourself.
Why do media outlets present overly optimistic financial narratives?
Research shows multiple drivers: journalist connections to company management lead to more favourable coverage, media naturally highlights dramatic developments disproportionately, and politically polarised outlets frame financial news differently. In the article, the specific example illustrates how a confident TV report, accompanied by charts, can present a distortion as fact, misleading viewers who lack the tools or inclination to verify the claims independently.
What was the actual state of the market in early January 2025?
In the article, the market is described as brimming with optimism that appeared unjustified by the fundamentals. Over the preceding two years, American company earnings had not kept pace with share prices. The resulting historically high P/E ratios suggested that a significant portion of the market's value was based on hope for future growth rather than current performance. Whether through price corrections or long-term stagnation, the current dynamic was described as unlikely to sustain itself.
Richard Golian

If you have any thoughts, questions, or feedback, feel free to drop me a message at mail@richardgolian.com.

NEWSLETTER
What I write about, what I am working on, what I learned.
Sent the first Sunday of the month. Unsubscribe anytime.

Related articles

Where the Money Goes When AI Takes the Work: Mapping the AI Economy

Prague, 13 May 2026. On my way to work I started thinking about something that stayed with me for days. If most routine work on a computer disappears in the next ten years, and a large share of repetitive manual work disappears with it, what happens to the flow of money? Who pays whom for what? Which economic layers will exist, how large will they be, and what relationships will run between them? This is the six-layer map I sketched as an answer.

15 May 2026·1 186 reads
AI, Algorithmic Trading, and Systemic Risk to Financial Stability

It is real, growing, and potentially devastating.

21 February 2025·2 301 reads
What Determines a Stock Price?

In April, in the first part of this series, I wrote about an AI prediction system I had started building on my own machine. At the time the software was a few hours old and the prediction record was empty. The record since then has shown one thing: the system does not yet understand the market it is being asked to forecast. It can pull macro context, book value, earnings. But it cannot put those together into something that helps it understand the price.

23 May 2026·565 reads

More articles

Dependent on AI: Are We Still Masters, or Slaves?

I have Heidegger and my notebook beside me. I am asking where all of this is heading, where artificial intelligence is taking us.

21 June 2026·436 reads
Which Work Will AI Not Replace?

Seventy per cent. That is where the first AI output begins, even when you give it the full company context and the best examples from the past. We are talking about the kind of output that cannot be defined programmatically. It is more complex. Often it is creative work. On one repeated type of output I reached eighty per cent within a week. Every further percentage point is harder than the one before.

10 June 2026·431 reads
What is the dead internet theory? Will we return offline?

For a long time we treated the internet as the main road. The place where work and relationships happen. Yet most of what we see on it today is, or soon will be, AI-generated: text, images, profiles and comments. The internet is turning into an online game full of bots, where you cannot be sure that a human is on the other side of anything. So I ask: was the online world the main road, or only a temporary detour that part of us will return from, back offline?

7 June 2026·482 reads
The Gap Between Professionals in the AI Era

A few days ago I interviewed a senior marketer. An experienced man, years of practice. I asked him about AI. He said he barely uses it. He had one bad experience with the output and decided he was too senior for it to add value when it is not perfect. I know the other side too: professionals who automate everything that can be automated.

6 June 2026·544 reads
Europe Is Not Ready for Drone Warfare

Europe does not have the capacity to face a full-scale, mass drone war of the kind we see in Ukraine. Three dependencies weaken it: China supplies the physical material for defence systems, the United States supplies capabilities Europe does not have, and twenty-seven states cannot agree how fast, or who pays. Rearmament plans exist, but they are being carried out slowly.

31 May 2026·499 reads
Can AI Replace Human Judgement?

AI produces the graphic, the newsletter and the product page faster than a person. What is left for the one who used to do it is the judgement, knowing whether the output is good. But most people have worse judgement than AI. And whoever cannot judge quality cannot delegate either. How do you tell whether yours is the judgement a company relies on, or the kind it can replace?

30 May 2026·502 reads
Can AI Predict the Stock Market? Building a Calibrated System

I am building an AI system to predict the S&P 500. It runs on my own machine, uses free public data (yfinance, FRED, the Shiller dataset), and grades every forecast against reality. This series documents the build itself: the decisions, the methodology, the mistakes. What I will eventually share from the running system is a separate question, and an honest one.

26 April 2026·1 488 reads
AI sales forecast: 9 traps so far

Yesterday I could not tear myself away from the computer. When I lifted my head, it was half past eight in the evening. I had been sitting alone upstairs for about three hours.

25 April 2026·1 026 reads
All in on AI agents, or an analogue life.

Four days in Catalonia. No computer, no AI, almost no social media. I bought this notebook so that I could write down what I would think about, and what I would come across and learn on the trip.

10.5.2026·935 reads
NEWSLETTER
What I write about, what I am working on, what I learned.
Sent the first Sunday of the month. Unsubscribe anytime.